Ecological Restoration
Ecological Restoration  

Ecological Restoration free content

table of contents, article abstracts, and photos

Subscriber? Click here for the full online edition of this and other issues

Volume 27 Number 2 June 2009

University of Wisconsin Arboretum

Where Restoration Emerged: A Gem of a Reserve Celebrates Its Diamond Anniversary by Joy B. Zedler

Society for Ecological Restoration International

A Brave New World by George Gann

Policy Report

Launching a National Restoration Coalition by Jennifer Heller

Perspective

A Science of Land Individuals by Thomas B. Simpson

Relevance of Natural Recovery to Ecological Restoration by Andre Clewell and Tein McDonald

Restoration Notes

Austin Is a Habitat Haven with National Wildlife Federation Certification by Alice V. Nance

Austin City Hall's certified wildlife habitat (NWF No. 99,000) is alive with native plants like bald cypress, yellow bells, inland sea oats, and horsetail. These plants provide natural food sources, cover, and places to raise young for birds, butterflies, dragonflies, and bees. Water is a key element of any habitat and can be incorporated simply with a shallow saucer of water and a rock for perching and basking. Photos by Victor Ovalle

Native Sod Rescue- A Viable Business Model (Montana) by Giles Cassidy Thelen and Kelly J. Dixon, Native Yards



A Plan for Landscape Fire Restoration in the Southwestern Borderlands by Gerald J. Gottfried and Larry S. Allen

Prescribed burning on one of 12 experimental watersheds in the Peloncillo Mountains, New Mexico. Operations were conducted by the Douglas Ranger District, Coronado National Forest in March 2008. Jackson Leonard, an ecologist with the Forest Service's Rocky Mountain Research Station in Flagstaff, Arizona, is on the fireline. A yellow infrared thermometer gun to measure fire temperatures remotely is suspended at his side. Photo by Gerald Gottfried

Restoring Burned Areas at Zion National Park (Utah) by Kelly Fuhrmann, Karen Weber and Cheryl Decker

Restoring Native Sedge Meadow Vegetation with a Combination of Herbicides (Illinois) by Thomas B. Simpson


Postsettlement Alluvium Removal: A Novel Floodplain Restoration Technique (Wisconsin) by Eric G. Booth, Steven P. Loheide II and Robert D. Hansis

The Effect of Disturbance History on Hawkweed Invasion (Montana) by Alexis Jones and Elizabeth Crone

Reducing Grouse Collision Mortality by Marking Fences (Oklahoma) by Donald H. Wolfe, Michael A. Patten and Steve K. Sherrod

Articles

Beyond Historic Baselines: Restoring Bolson Tortoises to Pleistocene Range by Joe Truett and Mike Phillips

Ecological restoration in North America traditionally has strived to return ecosystems to some semblance of the early historic (post-Columbian) condition. Emerging alternative paradigms recognize the large impacts exerted by pre-Columbian peoples, the ever-changing nature of ecosystems regardless of anthropogenic effects, and the possibility of using other benchmarks. Recently, the Turner Endangered Species Fund (TESF) initiated a project to restore the endangered bolson tortoise to an area in southern New Mexico within its late Pleistocene, but not historic, range. Justifications included the likelihood that prehistoric humans extirpated it from New Mexico, the presence of habitats similar to those in its current range in Mexico, and escalating threats to the species there. Thirty tortoises long kept captive outdoors in Arizona, another part of its prehistoric range, formed the basis for the restoration effort. The TESF and the Living Desert Zoo and Gardens State Park near Carlsbad, New Mexico maintain the adults in outdoor enclosures, and incubate eggs and rear young in smaller facilities. The TESF is initiating studies to assess whether the species can persist in the wild in New Mexico. Restoring imperiled species to prehistoric ranges has some precedent in North America and, we believe, merits increasing consideration as historic ranges of some species offer increasingly less security.

Uncertainty in Georeferencing Current and Historic Plant Locations by Kathryn McEachern and Ken Niessen

With shrinking habitats, weed invasions, and climate change, repeated surveys are becoming increasingly important for rare plant conservation and ecological restoration. We often need to relocate historical sites or provide locations for newly restored sites. Georeferencing is the technique of giving geographic coordinates to the location of a site. Georeferencing has been done historically using verbal descriptions or field maps that accompany voucher collections. New digital technology gives us more exact techniques for mapping and storing location information. Error still exists, however, and even georeferenced locations can be uncertain, especially if error information is not included with the observation. We review the concept of uncertainty in georeferencing and compare several institutional database systems for cataloging error and uncertainty with georeferenced locations. These concepts are widely discussed among geographers, but ecologists and restorationists need to become more aware of issues related to uncertainty to improve our use of spatial information in field studies.

Germination Timing and Dormancy Break in Seeds of Summer Farewell (Dalea pinnata, Fabaceae) by Hector E. Pérez, Fé Almira and Meghan Brennan

Summer farewell (Dalea pinnata) is a legume found in upland ecosystems throughout the southeastern United States. Often used in seed mixes for restoration purposes, it represents an opportunity for the emerging native seed industry in this region. Yet its germination characteristics are not well known. Our objective was to assess the germination timing and potential dormancy mechanisms of summer farewell. We specifically addressed the following questions: 1) to what extent do seeds germinate after shedding? 2) do seeds possess physical dormancy? and 3) can germination be enhanced using dormancy-breaking treatments? Summer farewell seeds germinated to a limited extent upon shedding, and most seeds (> 75%) in the population were shed with water-impermeable coats, or physical dormancy. Germination occurred equally well in light or darkness. Remaining ungerminated seeds displayed a high degree of viability (> 90%) after one year of burial. Thus summer farewell seeds are capable of forming soil seed banks. Scarification followed by incubation at constant temperatures yielded high germination. Germination of mechanically scarified seeds was superior to seeds scarified in acid for 5 or 10 minutes and unscarified seeds. However, incubation at 35°C may be deleterious. We discuss recommendations for restoration practitioners and seed producers.

Socioeconomic Barriers and the Role of Biomass Utilization in Southwestern Ponderosa Pine Restoration by Evan Hjerpe, Jesse Abrams and Dennis R. Becker

There is general consensus that ecological restoration of southwestern ponderosa pine systems is necessary and there exists ample ecological science suggesting that it is physically attainable. However, the pace of restoration has been noticeably slow and is far from approaching the landscape level. We conducted a review of published journal articles, book chapters, and proceedings on the restoration of ponderosa pine forests in the Southwest in order to identify and examine the primary socioeconomic barriers that are impeding the progress of ecological restoration in the region. The role of small-diameter wood utilization in the southwestern United States is highlighted as an example of broader, divergent socioeconomic contexts needing reconciliation if restoration is to expand to the ecosystem scale. A synthesis of opportunities for overcoming barriers and furthering the progress of forest restoration is provided.

An Invitation for Public Participation in Ecological Restoration: The Reasonable Person Model by Kimberly Bosworth Phalen

Public support plays a critical role in the completion and long-term success of ecological restoration projects. However, gaining this support has been a challenge in some cases. Local citizens have not always responded positively to restoration despite its touted benefits. In this article, I apply a theory of human behavior, motivation, and cognition called the Reasonable Person Model (RPM) in order to show how participation can be an effective part of restoration efforts. Using two case studies from Chicago, I discuss some of the issues that arise in restoration projects and how RPM may address them. This model identifies three important human needs, which when met contribute to more cooperative, reasonable behavior: cognitive map-building, meaningful action, and being effective. I demonstrate how RPM can be used to explain people's reactions to restoration efforts and why participation works better in some cases than in others. I also present strategies based on RPM to promote more effective participation in restoration efforts.

The Gift (book excerpt) by Courtney White


Soil Nitrogen Concentrations in a Restored Sedge Meadow Wetland as Affected by the Application of High C:N Amendments by Basil V. Iannone III, Carl J. Rosen and Susan M. Galatowitsch

Invasive perennial species are frequently a barrier to native plant establishment in fertile sedge meadow wetland restorations. Amending soils with high carbon-to-nitrogen (C:N) materials may deplete nitrogen (N) and limit the establishment of invasive species, although the effectiveness of such amendments at depleting soil N in restored wetlands is largely unknown. Therefore we incorporated four high C:N materials (cedar, white pine, and red oak sawdust, as well as sucrose) into the soils of nonvegetated plots in a restored sedge meadow wetland and measured soil ammonium-N and nitrate- N in relation to nonamended control plots over a 25-week period. All amendments depleted nitrate-N concentrations equivalently (67%-100%), although both the timing and the duration of this depletion varied among amendments. White pine sawdust was most effective, depleting nitrate-N for the entire 25 weeks. Sawdust from red oak and cedar depleted nitrate-N after 5 and 13 weeks, respectively. Lowered nitrate-N concentrations then persisted for the remaining 20 weeks in the red oak treatments, while the effects of cedar were short-lived (8 weeks). Sucrose depleted nitrate-N for 13 weeks. No amendment depleted ammonium-N concentrations, although cedar sawdust caused initial ammonium-N concentrations to increase by 300%-700%. Based on our findings, white pine sawdust will be more likely to deplete N effectively during the establishment of sedge meadow wetlands. It is unknown, however, if this depletion will suppress invasive perennials long enough to allow desired native species to establish a closed canopy and take up nitrogen, thereby limiting the chances of future invasions.

Revegetation of a Trampled Cliff-Edge Using Three-Toothed Cinquefoil and Poverty Grass: A Case Study at Tettegouche State Park, Minnesota by Joel P. Olfelt, David P. Olfelt and Jennifer L. Ison

Cliffs and cliff-edges are often attractive places to humans, and therefore may become damaged through recreational activities. Restoring cliffs and cliff-edges, which can be important sites of biodiversity, is challenging in part because of insufficient knowledge about native plant restoration techniques for these ecologically distinct areas. The cliff-edge at Shovel Point in Tettegouche State Park, Minnesota, has been damaged by heavy visitor use. We propagated 450 threetoothed cinquefoil (Potentilla tridentata) and 450 poverty grass (Danthonia spicata) plants from locally obtained seed to test revegetation techniques. We seeded plots with cinquefoil and poverty grass seeds for comparison with transplanted plots, we monitored survivorship and seedling recruitment for three seasons, and we counted the number of new shoots produced at 3 and 24 months after transplantation. Visitor access to planted areas was restricted during the study. Overall survival rates at 3, 13, and 24 months were 87.3%, 76.9%, and 68.9% for three-toothed cinquefoil and 98.7%, 96.7%, and 63.8% for poverty grass. The grand mean number of new shoots produced per plant was 0.37 and 2.11 (SE = 0.227, 0.365) at 3 and 24 months respectively for three-toothed cinquefoil and -0.21 and -3.15 (SE = 0.584, 0.295) at 3 and 24 months respectively for poverty grass. Only one seeded plot had a single poverty grass plant by the end of the study. One-way ANOVA tests revealed no statistically significant differences among treatments within species for survival or number of new shoots produced. We conclude that when transplanted, three-toothed cinquefoil and poverty grass are useful species for revegetation of damaged outcrops such as Shovel Point.

Book Reviews

Revolution on the Range: The Rise of a New Ranch in the American West. Courtney White. 2008. Washington DC: Island Press. Cloth, $25.95. ISBN: 978-1-59726-174-6. 248 pages. Reviewed by Mark Powell

Habitat Management for Conservation: A Handbook of Techniques. Malcolm Ausden. 2008. New York: Oxford University Press. Cloth, $150.00. ISBN: 978-0-19-856872-8. Paper, $75.00. ISBN: 978-0-19-856873-5. 384 pages. Reviewed by Penny Anderson

Large-Scale Ecosystem Restoration: Five Case Studies from the United States. Mary Doyle and Cynthia A. Drew, editors. 2008. Washington DC: Island Press. Cloth, $70.00. ISBN: 978-1-59726-025-1. Paper, $35.00. ISBN: 978-1-59726-026-8. 344 pages. Reviewed by Holly Doremus

Mycelium Running: How Mushrooms Can Help Save the World. Paul Stamets. 2005. Berkeley: Ten Speed Press. Paper. $35.00. ISBN: 978-1-58-008579-3. 339 pages. Reviewed by Daniel L. Lindner